Home > Old Wives Tales > No Coat in the Cold Causes Pneumonia

No Coat in the Cold Causes Pneumonia

By: Chris Welsh - Updated: 4 Dec 2012 | comments*Discuss
 
Rhino Virus Cold Flu Pneumonia Wives

Playing out in the cold without a coat on seems to rank right up there with stealing and smart mouthing when it comes to affronts against mothers and many a child has been brought up short when caught out without a coat. But does exposure to cold actually result in catching the flu, the common cold, or pneumonia, or is it just another wives tale?

The Cold Causes Colds Wives Tale

Today modern medicine has progressed to the point where people are living longer, more active, and generally healthier lives that at any other place in history, yet people everywhere still argue over whether or not getting caught out in the cold without proper protection will cause someone to get sick. The general idea is that getting physically cold lowers the immunes system, thereby opening up the body to sickness. In an odd way this makes a sort of sense by looking at the reverse- raising the body temperature in the form of a fever is the body’s way of fighting infection, so wouldn’t lowering the body temperature help infection? This reasoning is specious at best, however, and recently proved to be untrue.

East Versus West

There are still plenty of cultures that hold fast to the belief that cold is the enemy of the body, and one of the many ways it is harmful is by causing illness; likewise there are plenty of people in all cultures that believe the same. While arguments can—and are—made for both sides of the aisle, it is important to take a look at what actually causes a person to contract a cold, the flu, or pneumonia.

Virus

Illness is brought on by a virus taking hold in the body and circumventing—or overwhelming—the body’s immune system. The question, then, is whether or not getting cold has an effect on a person’s susceptibility to a virus. First of all if a virus is not present, getting very cold is not going to produce one out of nothingness, so the argument of no coat in the cold causing sickness is wrong to begin with. But why, then, do more people get sick in the winter months than other times of the year? Accepting for the moment that this is true, a popular believe is because people are more in contact with each other in closer quarters. As people stay indoors there is more exposure during the winter months to each other, which facilitates the spread of virus and resultant disease. Ironically it is those moments when people are vulnerable when they are NOT wearing their coats.

Final Thoughts

Another wives tale is that sitting near an open window or in front of air conditioning can bring on sickness as well. This might have come from the air drying out a person’s nasal passages and making them uncomfortable and experience cold like symptoms, but it doesn’t mystically transfer illness to a body. Keep in mind that it wasn’t so long ago in terms of human evolution that taking more than one bath a year was considered bad for you as well.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Boab
    Re: Where Does the Name Nylon Originate?
    I remember seeing a BBC documentary about Wallace Carothers, in which the New York-London idea was debunked. It seems…
    29 August 2020
  • Yvonne
    Re: Do Birds Flying Into A Home Equate To Death?
    Ive had a woidpecker. Pecking at my bedroom window. A few times in last couple wks. Then while i was camping…
    3 July 2020
  • Oskaras
    Re: Spilling Salt
    But if i throw some salt over my left shoulder and i get some under my nails, and then the salt falls out is it still considered bad luck? I ask…
    30 June 2020
  • Alex
    Re: Women on Board Ship - Bad Luck
    I'm 99% sure that the figurehead in the image at the top of this page is mine. It was attached to our 1930 wooden schooner but…
    21 June 2020
  • Sammy
    Re: A Black Cat Crossing Your Path
    I saw two maybe three black cats on my porch one stood in front of my door way as I was knocking to get in I had no key so I…
    25 May 2020
  • Kay Kay
    Re: A Black Cat Crossing Your Path
    A black cat came on my patio looked in my screen door at me and I made eye contact with it then it walked away. What does that…
    19 April 2020
  • Candice27
    Re: Spilling Salt
    However I would like you to contact me and I need more explanation I need to understand more things and if it’s your desire to help Someone please…
    5 March 2020
  • Mom3
    Re: A Black Cat Crossing Your Path
    Came on my front porch to a black cat lying in a broken chair not afraid of me or my kids at all ....is this bad
    19 November 2019
  • God
    Re: The Number 13
    I died being the 13th guest at a supper and now I hope no one will think 13 is a good number and love to you all and I am so sorry for your loss lily.
    13 November 2019
  • mdg85
    Re: Do Birds Flying Into A Home Equate To Death?
    6 years ago, I was visiting my mon & grandma at my mom's house. While there, a bird flew into my mom's back…
    3 November 2019